ABOUT LARGE CHAMBER SOPRANO PIECES
So, here’s a picture of 5 vintage large chamber soprano mouthpieces side by side. This picture alone should tell you something right away. Each of these pieces are very good players since I cleaned up the ubiquitous table and facing issues. That said, they are so different, one to the next, that calling them “large chamber” mouthpieces is not very useful.
Figure it out: if the internal volume of these pieces are more or less equal, which they are, then their chamber shapes must be drastically different to accomodate the obvious difference in external dimensions.And they are different.
So: why is that? Well, it’s because the shape of the chamber has way more to do with the sound than the nomeenclature of “large chamber”. We should be speaking about “deep chamber” or “wide chamber” or “low chamber” or high chamber”, and more.
This idea that the “throat” (the opening in the chamber just before the neck of the horn), which has become the ‘standard” for calling these pieces “large chamber”, is a controlling factor or even a significant factor in how pieces like these perform and sound, is just foolishness.
There’s a reason that the major mouthpiece makers of the past all stopped making large chamber soprano mouthpieces. The simple reason is they developed a superior design that played better and offered all the same potential for tone and response. And the new design was simpler to produce as well, besides being easier for most players to play. But that doesn’t lessen the beauty of these “large chamber” pieces in the least. It just reorients them in our thinking.
Pieces such as these and others make significantly different demands on a player. It’s not that they are harder to play but they require more from the player if they are to play in tune consistently.
In the case of these 5 pieces, we have the squat, wide Otto Link slant and the even squatter Martin. But we have the longer chamber of the Meyer, which is by default also narrower. Their sounds are different but, more importantly, their response and feel is very different.
Crude analogy, but, here it is anyway: if you try to blow up new balloons, you may notice that the longer, thinner ones require less force of air than the big rounder ones require. That is, in many ways, like the feel that one “large chamber” piece can have and another, with a different shaped chamber, will not have or will have much less of.
I see and play more soprano mouthpieces than anyone I know, and by “play”, I mean PLAY, not just toot. The things I’ve mentioned are not theories but things that I have ddiscovered over a long period of time. Keep them in mind when you are dealing with any mouthpiece for soprano that is playing great for you or is fighting you in some way. The answers are usually right in the chamber itself.